Hacker News monitoring: catch the right thread
How to monitor Hacker News for buying conversations, score each comment 0 to 100 for intent, and reply without getting flagged by a crowd that hates a pitch.
By Max Gillespie, founder of Oetzi
A Hacker News monitoring tool has to read comments, not story titles, because the buying conversation usually sits three levels deep in a thread about something else. Oetzi compiles one sentence describing that conversation into native Hacker News searches, scores every match 0 to 100 for buying intent, and drafts a reply you approve.
What buying conversations look like on Hacker News
Four shapes are worth watching. The Ask HN where someone asks what the crowd uses for a job. The comment thread under an unrelated story where two people compare vendors and a third asks which one wins. The Show HN where a founder ships something adjacent to yours and the comments fill with people describing what they need. And the complaint about a price change, where the replies become a list of alternatives within an hour.
The audience is technical and buys tools with a company card. One good comment can send traffic for years, because these threads rank in search and AI engines quote them when someone asks what to use.
How Oetzi turns one sentence into Hacker News searches
You describe the conversation, not the keyword. "Developers asking what to replace their log search with" is a signal. Oetzi compiles it into native searches across stories and comments plus a rubric for what counts, backfills the last seven days, then sweeps on your cadence. One sweep of one signal across every platform is 2 credits and refunds when nothing qualifies.
Each match gets an intent score from 0 to 100 with the reason written out and a tag for who is talking: buyer, current customer, feature request, or competitor user. A comment naming a budget and a migration date scores high. A tangent about the category scores low. That is the difference between social listening and a keyword alert that forwards every mention of your name.
How to reply on Hacker News without getting flagged
Read the Hacker News guidelines before you comment. They ask you to keep the site for curious conversation rather than promotion, and users and moderators both enforce that. Comments get flagged, accounts get rate limited, and a flagged comment disappears from the thread.
The practical rules. Marketing language is the fastest way to get flagged, so write like an engineer explaining a tradeoff. Disclose in the first line that you work on the thing. Be specific about what your product does badly, since that is what buys credibility. Name a competitor when the competitor is the honest answer. Skip the link unless someone asks. Do not reply to every thread in your category, and never bring friends in to vote. Oetzi drafts two variants in your voice and nothing goes out without your approval.
A good comment reads like this: "We hit this at about two hundred gigabytes a day. Sampling at the agent was the only thing that helped. I work on X, which does that, though it will not help if your bottleneck is query latency." Technical, honest about limits, one mention, then you stop.
Questions
Does Hacker News have keyword alerts?
Hacker News itself does not send alerts. Search covers stories and comments, and third party tools poll it on a schedule. Oetzi treats it as one of seven platforms, compiles your one-sentence description into searches over both, scores each match, and sends the high scores to your inbox, to Slack, or by text.
Will Hacker News flag me for mentioning my own product?
Not automatically. The guidelines allow posting your own work some of the time, as long as the account is mostly there for conversation. What gets flagged is marketing language, a comment that answers nothing, or an account that is one product name. Disclose the affiliation, answer the question first, and stay useful when your product is irrelevant.
Is Hacker News better than Reddit for finding users?
They pay off differently. Hacker News has fewer threads and a harsher audience, but one good comment reaches many technical buyers at once. Reddit monitoring finds more conversations in more niches, including non technical ones. Founders selling developer tools watch both and reply first where the intent score is highest.
Oetzi is an AI marketer for founders who need users. It finds the threads where people ask for a product like yours on seven platforms, checks whether the AI engines recommend you, and drafts replies, posts, and short video in your voice. You approve everything. 100 credits included, 10 free to try with no card, 50 bonus credits with the first payment.
- Bluesky monitoring: find posts asking what to useHow to monitor Bluesky for buying conversations, score each post 0 to 100 for intent, and reply on an open network where founders still talk in public.
- LinkedIn monitoring: find posts where buyers askHow to monitor LinkedIn for buying conversations, score each post for intent, and comment in a way that fits LinkedIn comment culture and gets you noticed.
- Reddit monitoring: find threads asking for a toolHow to monitor Reddit for buying conversations, score them for intent, and reply without getting banned. What a good founder reply on Reddit looks like.
- Substack Notes monitoring: find writers askingHow to monitor Substack Notes for buying conversations, score each note 0 to 100 for intent, and reply in a feed where writers talk shop with writers.
- Threads monitoring: find posts asking for your toolHow to monitor Meta's Threads for buying conversations, score each post for intent, and reply on a young, open surface where small accounts still get heard.